Why I chose Hyundai Venue instead of other cars - eNidhi India Travel Blog

Why I chose Hyundai Venue instead of other cars

 As information about me having booked a Hyundai Venue was shared on twitter and FB, many have asked me why Venue? Why not Nexon or Ecosport or something else. This post is to explain my rationale, limitations and thought process. I could be wrong or it may not match with your line of thinking. I am not saying I am correct and all have to follow it. Use this as reference and use your discretion.

When I made up my mind to buy a car, I was 100% sure I want a new car. But all cars in 5-6 Lakh budget were very unsafe, didn't have passenger airbag or didn't have basic features related to comfort and convenience. [Detailed thought here]. Thus I decided to spend a lakh more and booked Tata Tiago XZ in December 2020.

But over next 1 month I found so many issues with Tata Motors Udupi (no service centre, no mechanic, no stockyard, car will be driven by road from Mangalore, total lack of communication etc). Thus I started looking for Option 2.

I went to Hyundai showroom to check Grand i10 Nios. I was costing almost 8 lakhs(50k more than Tiago XZ), had lesser ground clearance and had got only 2 star safety rating. I didn't want to consider Maruti or Renault at that time. I saw Venue S+, which costed 10.2 lakhs on road but for the extra 2.2 lakhs (compared to Nios) offered following things extra

- It is a few categories above hatchback (Compact SUV>Premium Hatch> Standard Hatch> Budget Hatch)

- Higher ground clearance (190 mm compared to Tiago's 170 and Nios 165mm)

- Few extra features compared to Tiago XZ- Auto AC, rear camera, corner headlamp, projector headlamp, rear seat height adjustment, driver arm rest etc

Thus I made up my mind to extend my budget to 10 Lakhs and Book a Venue.

But then, if someone is spending 10 lakhs, below is what you can get

#

Category

Examples

Pros

Cons

1

Premium Hatchbacks, near top variants

Altroz

New i20

Jazz

Lots of features

Still a hatchback

Lower Ground Clearance

2

MPV- Entry to mid variants

Ertiga Lxi

Triber RXZ

7 seats

No everyday use of 7 seats

Top variants cost more

3

Compact SUV- entry to mid variants

Venue S, S+

Nexon XM

Ecosport

Brezza LXi

High ground clearance

A more popular category

 

Premium features like sunroof, turbo engines, Auto transmission etc cost a few lakhs more

4

Compact Sedans- top variants

Aura

Tigor

Amaze

Little extra space (boot)

Most features of corresponding hatch’s top variant

Segment losing popularity now due to compact sedans

Low ground clearance

Hatchback with a small boot

 

 

 

 

 


Premium Sedans like Verna cost 13-15 lakhs now on road. Premium SUVs like Creta, Harrier cost 20-22 lakhs while full size proper SUVs (Endeavor, Fortuner etc) cost 35-40 lakhs.

So I decided to stick to Compact SUVs and within 10 lakhs on road price. Once I made up my mind on this, below were my options. Please note that when I say 10 lakhs I mean on road price. This means I need to chose a car whose ex-showroom price is under 8.5 lakhs (on road price is 20-25% more than ex-showroom price)

#

Model

Pros

Cons

Remarks

1

Ford Ecosport

(Ambiente or trend only)

4 star rating

Proven vehicle

6-7 year old design

Ford’s future in India uncertain

Didn’t evaluate as I wasn’t sure if Ford will continue in India

2

Tata Nexon (XM, XM(S) only)

5 star rating

Poor deal experience

Didn’t consider any Tata cars because of poor experience with Tiago

3

Kia Sonet

HTK or HTK Plus

 

 

Didn’t consider because of 3 month waiting period. Build similar to Venue

4

Mahindra XUV300

W4

5 star rating, service center in Udupi & Kundapura

Only W4 in budget, all others are beyond 10 lakhs

W4 didn't have any features, W6/W8 beyond budget.

5

Venue S+

 

 

Felt like good choice among options, right compromise of power, features and basic needs

6

Magnite

Cheaper, loaded

6+ month waiting

New car, safety & feedback not known

Was unable to trust Nissan brand, hence didn't consider

7

Reno Kiger

RXT

Cheaper by 2 lakhs

Lots of features

 

New car, safety & feedback not known

 

8

Brezza VXi

4 star

Lots of cars on road

 

Only ZXI has decent list of features, beyond my budget. VXi not much

9

WRV

 

 

Didn’t evaluate

10

Urban Cruiser

 

 

Didn’t evaluate: Brezza+50k premium


I narrowed down what I wanted in my car.
- Decent ground clearance- have some bad roads in my hometown- a bit more ground clearance will give more confidence and comfort.
- Reasonable power, not too little, not too low. I don't want to race with anyone and prove I have the faster car, but I also don't want to crawl on a highway during weekend trips.
- Driver height adjustment
- Some comfort for 2nd row passengers
- Decent music system- need not be top notch but not ultra cheap either
- A vehicle that is proven, reliable and likely to last 5-10 years without issues
- Decent after sales service near my town.
- Trustworthy build quality and safety- Venue got 4 star in Australian NCAP. Global NCAP rating not known, Hyundai may do cost cutting for India makes. But didn't see much videos on Venue accidents and crashes, so assuming not many major incidents have happened with this car and it can be trusted.

I also decided things on which I won't waste my money
- Sunroof
- Alloy wheels
- Turbo/ too much power which I can hardly use
- Auto Transmission
- Ambient lights
- Push button start

Venue S+ ticked most of the boxes. Earlier Venue had only E and S. S+ was introduced mid 2020 with some more features over S. More expensive variants like SX, SX(O) with sunroof, turbo, DCT etc cost 2-3 lakhs more, so I decided to avoid them and stick with the variant within my budget. S+ still has some limitations I am aware and will live with it
- Instrument cluster is old style, not more advanced ones used in SX and not fully digital like in Kiger or Nexon
- No power to windows after key is taken off
- Armrest for second row passengers (not even an option)
- If not alloy wheels, wheel covers made to look like alloy wheels would have been nice. I will use stock tyres and wheels for 30000 kms. Then will change better tyre and alloy wheel as per my choice.

Venue S+ price increased by 7k since Jan. No price protection was offered unlike Tata Motors. Also absolutely no offer/discount for Venue and Creta (Hyundai's top selling models)

With Tata, Ford, Kia, Nissan and Maruti brands ruled out due to various reasons such as after sales service, waiting period etc, I was left with Hyundai, Reno and Honda. Of these options I felt Hyundai Venue is the best fit. Did I make the right choice? I will know after few months.

I am not saying Venue S+ is the best thing you can buy. If you can extend by a few lakhs there are more powerful, more feature loaded cars. You can also opt for premium hatchbacks like Altroz or i20 in this price range or compact sedans like Amaze. Use your discretion.

RelatedVenue PDI checklist * Is Venue S underpowered? * Venue Owner Review * 

2 comments:

  1. Believe me you will enjoy riding the Hyundai ,sometimes you have to be careful to know that the car is still running since its so silent.

    ReplyDelete

Appreciate your efforts and interests to comment. Comments may be moderated due to increased spam. Will ideally respond to comments within few days.Use Anonymous option if you don't wish to leave your name/ID behind- Shrinidhi

Powered by Blogger.